What Year Toyota Highlander To Avoid When Buying Used?

What Year Toyota Highlander To Avoid? Knowing the answer is essential for a reliable purchase, and at millertoyota.net, we guide you toward the best choices. Steer clear of the 2003, 2008, 2014, and 2015 models to dodge potential headaches. Opting for the right model year can save you from costly repairs and ensure a smoother driving experience. Discover dependable Highlander options at Miller Toyota in Boise, ensuring your next SUV is a lasting investment and for robust options, consider models from 2017 onward.

1. Understanding The Toyota Highlander’s Reliability

The Toyota Highlander has earned a stellar reputation for reliability, but it’s wise to be aware of certain model years that have presented more challenges than others. While Toyota is renowned for producing dependable vehicles, not every Highlander year has enjoyed the same level of success. Choosing the right model year is crucial to ensuring a vehicle that stands the test of time, providing years of dependable service. So, which Toyota Highlander should you avoid?

1.1. Why Researching Highlander Model Years Matters

Researching Highlander model years is essential for several reasons:

Avoiding Costly Repairs: Certain model years have a higher likelihood of developing expensive issues like engine problems or transmission failures.
Ensuring Reliability: Opting for a more reliable year translates to fewer unexpected breakdowns and more peace of mind.
Maximizing Resale Value: A well-maintained, reliable Highlander will hold its value better over time.
Optimizing Ownership Experience: A dependable vehicle simply offers a more enjoyable and stress-free ownership experience.

By doing your homework and identifying which Toyota Highlander years to avoid, you significantly increase your chances of landing a vehicle that will serve you well for years. Miller Toyota, located in Boise, is dedicated to providing detailed information and professional guidance to help you make an informed decision. With our expertise, you can confidently choose a Highlander that meets your needs and exceeds your expectations.

1.2. General Reliability of the Toyota Highlander

The Toyota Highlander is celebrated for its long-term reliability, making it a favorite among families and individuals alike. According to J.D. Power, the Highlander consistently scores high in reliability ratings, often outperforming other SUVs in its class. Its durable construction, dependable engine options, and overall build quality contribute to its strong reputation.

However, even with its generally positive track record, some model years have faced more issues than others. These can range from minor annoyances to more significant mechanical problems. By pinpointing the specific years to avoid, you can focus on models known for their consistent performance and durability.

2. Toyota Highlander Years To Avoid: A Comprehensive List

While the Toyota Highlander generally boasts impressive reliability, some model years have proven more problematic than others. Based on owner reports, repair data, and common issues, here’s a comprehensive list of Toyota Highlander years to avoid:

2003: Early models experienced transmission issues and excessive oil consumption.
2008: Known for excessive oil consumption and potential engine problems.
2014: Reported issues with the transmission, as well as electronic problems.
2015: Similar to the 2014 model, this year faced complaints about transmission performance and electronic glitches.

These model years have a higher incidence of reported problems, making them riskier choices in the used car market. While individual vehicles may vary, these years have a higher likelihood of requiring more frequent repairs and maintenance.

2.1. Deep Dive Into Problematic Years

Let’s delve deeper into the specific issues that plagued these Toyota Highlander model years:

2.1.1. 2003 Toyota Highlander

The 2003 Toyota Highlander, one of the initial models, faced notable challenges, especially concerning its transmission. Many owners reported experiencing harsh shifting, slipping gears, and, in some cases, complete transmission failure. These issues often surfaced at relatively low mileage, leading to significant repair costs.

Furthermore, the 2003 Highlander was also known for excessive oil consumption. Some owners found themselves adding oil far more frequently than expected, indicating potential engine wear or leaks. These combined issues make the 2003 model a less desirable option for those seeking a reliable used SUV.

2.1.2. 2008 Toyota Highlander

The 2008 Toyota Highlander stands out due to its widespread reports of excessive oil consumption. Owners frequently reported needing to add oil between scheduled oil changes, a telltale sign of potential engine issues.

While the 2008 Highlander had a redesign that boosted appeal, the engine problems overshadowed these improvements, making it a less attractive choice for buyers seeking a dependable SUV.

2.1.3. 2014 Toyota Highlander

The 2014 Toyota Highlander marked the beginning of the third generation, but it also brought a new set of challenges. One of the primary concerns was transmission issues, with owners reporting harsh shifting, hesitation, and occasional slipping.

Beyond transmission problems, the 2014 Highlander also faced complaints about its electronic systems. Issues ranged from malfunctioning infotainment screens to problems with the navigation system and other electronic accessories.

2.1.4. 2015 Toyota Highlander

The 2015 Toyota Highlander mirrored many of the issues found in the 2014 model, particularly regarding transmission performance. Owners continued to report similar problems with rough shifting and hesitation, raising concerns about the long-term reliability of the transmission.

Additionally, the 2015 Highlander also had its share of electronic issues, with ongoing complaints about the infotainment system and other electronic components. These recurring problems solidified the 2014 and 2015 models as years to approach with caution.

2.2. Common Problems And Their Impact

Understanding the specific issues associated with these Toyota Highlander years is crucial for making an informed decision. Here’s a closer look at some of the most common problems and their potential impact:

Problem	Description	Potential Impact
Transmission Issues	Harsh shifting, slipping gears, hesitation.	Reduced performance, potential for costly repairs, decreased lifespan of the transmission.
Excessive Oil Consumption	Needing to add oil frequently between changes.	Potential engine damage, increased maintenance costs, environmental concerns.
Electronic Problems	Malfunctioning infotainment screens, navigation issues, other electronic glitches.	Frustration, inconvenience, potential for costly repairs to electronic components.
Engine Bolts Stripping	Coolant leaks, overheating, potential engine failure.	Severe engine damage, costly repairs, potential for complete engine replacement.
Faulty Head Gasket	Engine overheating.	Significant engine damage, expensive repairs.

These issues can significantly impact the ownership experience, leading to increased maintenance costs, inconvenience, and potential long-term reliability concerns. Recognizing these potential pitfalls can help you make a more informed choice when considering a used Toyota Highlander.

3. Notable Issues With Specific Toyota Highlander Years

Beyond the broad strokes, some specific issues have plagued certain Toyota Highlander years. Awareness of these problems can further refine your decision-making process.

3.1. Engine Problems: Stripped Bolts And Failures

Engine problems are a significant concern for any car buyer, and the Toyota Highlander is no exception. Certain model years have been known for engine issues, including stripped engine bolts and engine failures.

3.1.1. Stripped Engine Bolts

One of the more severe problems reported in older Toyota Highlander models is stripped engine bolts. This issue typically involves the bolts that secure the engine head to the engine block. Over time, these bolts can become stripped, leading to coolant leaks and engine overheating.

If left unaddressed, stripped engine bolts can lead to catastrophic engine damage, often requiring a complete engine replacement. This problem is most common around 130,000 miles, but it can occur earlier or later depending on driving conditions and maintenance history.

3.1.2. Engine Failure

Engine failure, in general, is another significant concern for Toyota Highlander owners. While it can be caused by various factors, stripped engine bolts and subsequent overheating are often contributing factors. Other potential causes include:

Lack of Maintenance: Neglecting regular oil changes and other maintenance tasks can lead to premature engine wear and failure.
Overheating: Allowing the engine to overheat, whether due to a cooling system problem or other issues, can cause severe damage.
Manufacturing Defects: In rare cases, manufacturing defects can contribute to engine failure.

Engine failure can be a costly and disruptive problem, potentially requiring a complete engine replacement or even rendering the vehicle unusable.

3.2. Excessive Oil Consumption

Excessive oil consumption is another common complaint among Toyota Highlander owners, particularly in certain model years. This issue involves the engine burning through oil at a higher-than-normal rate, requiring owners to add oil more frequently between scheduled oil changes.

While some oil consumption is normal in any engine, excessive oil consumption can be a sign of underlying problems, such as:

Worn Piston Rings: Piston rings are responsible for sealing the combustion chamber and preventing oil from entering. Worn or damaged piston rings can allow oil to leak into the combustion chamber, where it’s burned along with the fuel.
Valve Seal Leaks: Valve seals prevent oil from leaking into the combustion chamber through the valve guides. Damaged or worn valve seals can result in increased oil consumption.
Cylinder Wear: Over time, the cylinder walls can wear down, creating gaps that allow oil to enter the combustion chamber.

Excessive oil consumption can lead to engine damage, reduced performance, and increased emissions. It’s essential to address this issue promptly to prevent further problems.

3.3. Fuel Tank And AC Condenser Problems (2020 Model)

The redesigned 2020 Toyota Highlander, while generally well-received, had its share of issues, particularly regarding the fuel tank and AC condenser.

3.3.1. Fuel Tank Capacity

Some owners reported that they could not fill the fuel tank to its advertised capacity of 17.1 gallons. Instead, they could only fill it to around 12-14 gallons. This issue can be frustrating, as it reduces the vehicle’s range and requires more frequent trips to the gas station.

3.3.2. AC Condenser Issues

The AC system in the 2020 Highlander also faced complaints, with some owners reporting that the AC condenser was prone to damage, causing the AC to stop blowing cool air. A faulty AC system can be a significant inconvenience, especially in hot weather.

These issues with the 2020 model highlight the importance of thoroughly inspecting any used vehicle before making a purchase, even if it’s a relatively new model.

3.4. Head Gasket And Oxygen Sensor Problems

Older Toyota Highlander models (2001-2007) have been known for head gasket and oxygen sensor issues, which can lead to significant engine problems.

3.4.1. Faulty Head Gasket

The head gasket seals the cylinder head to the engine block, preventing coolant and oil from leaking into the cylinders. In some older Highlanders, the head gasket is prone to failure, leading to engine overheating and potential damage.

3.4.2. Oxygen Sensor Problems

Faulty oxygen sensors can cause the engine to misfire, resulting in rough idling and reduced fuel efficiency. Replacing faulty oxygen sensors can resolve these issues, but it’s essential to address the problem promptly to prevent further engine damage.

4. Toyota Highlander Years To Buy: Reliable Options

Now that we’ve covered the Toyota Highlander years to avoid, let’s focus on the more reliable options. These model years have consistently earned high marks for dependability, making them excellent choices for used car buyers.

2001
2005
2006
2007
2009
2013
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021

These models have a proven track record of reliability and fewer reported problems than the years to avoid. They offer a balance of value, performance, and dependability.

4.1. Top Recommendations For Used Buyers

Among the reliable Toyota Highlander years, some stand out as particularly good choices for used car buyers:

4.1.1. 2005-2007 Toyota Highlander

These model years offer a sweet spot of reliability and affordability. They have a proven track record of dependability, and they’re generally available at reasonable prices in the used car market.

4.1.2. 2009 Toyota Highlander

The 2009 Toyota Highlander marked the beginning of the second generation, offering updated styling, improved features, and continued reliability. It’s a solid choice for those seeking a more modern Highlander without the higher price tag of newer models.

4.1.3. 2017-2019 Toyota Highlander

These more recent model years offer a blend of modern features, updated technology, and proven reliability. They’re a great choice for buyers who want a more contemporary Highlander with the peace of mind that comes with a dependable vehicle.

4.2. Factors Contributing To Reliability

Several factors contribute to the reliability of these Toyota Highlander years:

Proven Design: These models benefit from a well-established design and engineering, with fewer major changes or redesigns that could introduce new problems.
Durable Components: Toyota’s commitment to using high-quality components contributes to the long-term reliability of these models.
Positive Owner Feedback: Owners of these model years consistently report high levels of satisfaction and fewer problems compared to the years to avoid.

5. How To Choose The Right Toyota Highlander

Choosing the right Toyota Highlander involves more than just selecting a reliable model year. It also requires careful consideration of your individual needs, budget, and preferences. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you make the right choice:

Define Your Needs: Determine how you plan to use the Highlander. Do you need it for daily commuting, family trips, or hauling cargo?
Set a Budget: Determine how much you’re willing to spend. This will help you narrow down your options and focus on models within your price range.
Research Model Years: Refer to the list of Toyota Highlander years to avoid and prioritize the more reliable options.
Check Vehicle History: Obtain a vehicle history report (e.g., Carfax or AutoCheck) to check for accidents, title issues, and maintenance records.
Inspect the Vehicle: Conduct a thorough inspection of the vehicle, paying attention to the engine, transmission, brakes, and other critical components.
Take a Test Drive: Take the Highlander for a test drive to assess its performance, handling, and overall driving experience.
Consider a Pre-Purchase Inspection: Have a trusted mechanic perform a pre-purchase inspection to identify any potential problems before you buy.

By following these steps, you can increase your chances of finding a Toyota Highlander that meets your needs and provides years of reliable service.

5.1. Key Considerations Before Buying A Used Highlander

Before finalizing your purchase, consider the following key factors:

Mileage: Lower mileage vehicles typically have less wear and tear, but higher mileage vehicles may be more affordable.
Maintenance History: A well-maintained Highlander is more likely to be reliable in the long run.
Overall Condition: Assess the overall condition of the vehicle, including the interior, exterior, and mechanical components.
Warranty: Consider purchasing an extended warranty for added peace of mind, especially if you’re buying an older model.
Pricing: Research the fair market value of the Highlander you’re considering to ensure you’re getting a good deal.

5.2. Why Choose Miller Toyota In Boise?

When searching for your next Toyota Highlander, Miller Toyota in Boise offers several advantages:

Extensive Inventory: We have a wide selection of new and used Highlanders to choose from.
Certified Technicians: Our certified technicians thoroughly inspect every used vehicle to ensure its quality and reliability.
Competitive Pricing: We offer competitive pricing and financing options to fit your budget.
Exceptional Customer Service: Our friendly and knowledgeable staff is dedicated to providing exceptional customer service.
Convenient Location: Located in Boise, we’re easily accessible to customers throughout the Treasure Valley.

Visit millertoyota.net to explore our inventory, schedule a test drive, and experience the Miller Toyota difference. Address: 208 N Maple Grove Rd, Boise, ID 83704, United States. Phone: +1 (208) 376-8888.

6. Maintaining Your Toyota Highlander For Longevity

Proper maintenance is essential for ensuring the longevity and reliability of your Toyota Highlander. By following a regular maintenance schedule and addressing any issues promptly, you can keep your Highlander running smoothly for years.

6.1. Essential Maintenance Tasks

Here are some essential maintenance tasks to keep your Toyota Highlander in top condition:

Regular Oil Changes: Changing the oil and filter at the recommended intervals is crucial for engine lubrication and performance.
Fluid Checks: Regularly check and top off all fluids, including coolant, brake fluid, power steering fluid, and transmission fluid.
Tire Maintenance: Rotate and balance your tires regularly to ensure even wear and prolong their lifespan.
Brake Inspections: Inspect your brakes regularly and replace worn brake pads or rotors as needed.
Tune-Ups: Perform regular tune-ups to keep your engine running efficiently and prevent problems.

6.2. Addressing Common Issues Promptly

Addressing common issues promptly can prevent them from escalating into more significant problems. Be aware of the warning signs of potential problems, such as:

Unusual Noises: Pay attention to any unusual noises coming from the engine, transmission, or other components.
Leaks: Check for leaks under the vehicle, which could indicate fluid leaks.
Warning Lights: Don’t ignore warning lights on the dashboard, as they could indicate a serious problem.
Reduced Performance: Notice any decline in performance, such as reduced fuel efficiency or sluggish acceleration.

By addressing these issues promptly, you can prevent costly repairs and keep your Toyota Highlander running smoothly.

7. The Importance Of Vehicle History Reports

A vehicle history report, such as Carfax or AutoCheck, provides valuable information about a used vehicle’s past. This report can reveal important details about the vehicle’s history, including:

Accident History: Whether the vehicle has been involved in any accidents.
Title Issues: Whether the vehicle has a salvage, flood, or other title issues.
Odometer Readings: Verifies the accuracy of the odometer reading.
Maintenance Records: Provides a history of maintenance and repairs performed on the vehicle.
Number of Owners: Indicates how many previous owners the vehicle has had.

A vehicle history report can help you identify potential problems and make a more informed decision when buying a used Toyota Highlander.

7.1. Understanding Carfax And Autocheck Reports

Carfax and AutoCheck are two of the most popular vehicle history report providers. While they both offer similar information, there are some differences:

Data Sources: Carfax relies primarily on data from insurance companies, while AutoCheck uses data from auctions and other sources.
Scoring System: AutoCheck uses a scoring system to rank vehicles based on their history, while Carfax does not.
Cost: The cost of a Carfax or AutoCheck report can vary depending on the provider and the type of report you purchase.

Regardless of which provider you choose, obtaining a vehicle history report is a worthwhile investment when buying a used Toyota Highlander.

7.2. Red Flags To Watch Out For

When reviewing a vehicle history report, be on the lookout for these red flags:

Accident Damage: Evidence of significant accident damage can indicate potential structural or mechanical problems.
Title Issues: A salvage, flood, or other title issue can significantly reduce the value and reliability of the vehicle.
Odometer Discrepancies: Discrepancies in the odometer reading can indicate odometer fraud.
Gaps in Maintenance Records: Gaps in the maintenance records can suggest that the vehicle has not been properly maintained.
Multiple Owners: A large number of previous owners can indicate potential problems with the vehicle.

If you spot any of these red flags, proceed with caution and consider having the vehicle inspected by a qualified mechanic before making a purchase.

8. Toyota Highlander Alternatives To Consider

While the Toyota Highlander is a popular choice, there are several other SUVs that offer similar features, performance, and reliability. Here are some alternatives to consider:

Honda Pilot: The Honda Pilot is known for its spacious interior, comfortable ride, and reputation for reliability.
Kia Telluride: The Kia Telluride offers a stylish design, upscale interior, and a long list of standard features.
Hyundai Palisade: The Hyundai Palisade is similar to the Kia Telluride, offering a spacious interior, comfortable ride, and a strong value proposition.
Ford Explorer: The Ford Explorer offers a range of engine options, including a powerful EcoBoost V6, and a spacious interior.
Chevrolet Traverse: The Chevrolet Traverse offers a large cargo area and comfortable seating for up to eight passengers.

8.1. Comparing Features And Reliability

When considering these alternatives, compare their features, reliability ratings, and overall value proposition to determine which one best meets your needs. Here’s a quick comparison:

Vehicle	Features	Reliability	Value
Toyota Highlander	Spacious interior, strong resale value, available hybrid model	Excellent	Higher price point, but strong long-term value
Honda Pilot	Comfortable ride, spacious interior, good fuel economy	Excellent	Competitive pricing, well-rounded features
Kia Telluride	Stylish design, upscale interior, long list of standard features	Good	Excellent value for the money, long warranty
Hyundai Palisade	Similar to Telluride, spacious interior, comfortable ride	Good	Excellent value, similar to Telluride
Ford Explorer	Powerful engine options, spacious interior	Average	Competitive pricing, but reliability can be a concern
Chevrolet Traverse	Large cargo area, comfortable seating	Average	Competitive pricing, but reliability can be a concern

Consider your priorities and preferences when choosing between these alternatives.

8.2. Making The Right Choice For Your Needs

Ultimately, the right choice depends on your individual needs, budget, and preferences. Consider what’s most important to you in an SUV, whether it’s reliability, features, value, or performance, and choose the model that best meets those criteria.

9. Frequently Asked Questions: Toyota Highlander Years To Avoid

9.1. What Toyota Highlander years should I avoid in the used car market?

You should consider avoiding the Toyota Highlander from the years 2003, 2008, 2014, and 2015. These models have been identified as having more significant issues than other years.

9.2. Were there any Toyota Highlander models with notable engine problems?

Yes, some Toyota Highlander models experienced issues such as engine bolts becoming stripped, which led to coolant leaks and overheating and, in some cases, necessitating complete engine replacements. These problems were prevalent around 130,000 miles.

9.3. Has Toyota addressed the fuel tank issue in the 2020 Highlander model?

Toyota has acknowledged the fuel tank issue in the 2020 Highlander, where drivers could not fill the tank to its advertised capacity. Solutions may involve dealer service actions to check for and rectify any fuel tank assembly or design anomalies.

9.4. Which model years offer the best balance between cost and reliability for a used Toyota Highlander?

Models years 2001, 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2009 through 2013, as well as more recent models from 2017 to 2021, offer a good balance of cost and reliability. These years are less prone to the severe issues that plagued other models and are generally considered good investments.

9.5. Are Toyota Highlanders typically reliable?

Toyota’s reputation for dependability carries through to the Highlander, a trusted family hauler available in the U.S. for over 20 years. There are a few Toyota Highlander years to avoid (2003, 2008, 2014, and 2015), but most model years enjoy an excellent reputation for reliability.

9.6. How much does a used Toyota Highlander typically cost?

An older Highlander, such as one from 2002 with 100,000 miles, costs about $6,000. But prices on newer examples quickly rise as these are in-demand vehicles. Based on condition and equipment, expect to pay double or triple this amount for a 2012 Highlander. And thanks to a tight market, almost-new Highlanders have new car prices. According to CoPilot Price Pulse, a 2020 Toyota Highlander has an asking price of $38,158. That’s 17% higher than the car would sell for at regular times.

9.7. Is the Toyota Highlander a good car to purchase?

Yes, definitely. The Toyota Highlander is an excellent choice for a three-row crossover. With most model years enjoying good reliability, they are a safe bet as a used car. Of course, a warranty adds extra confidence if you’re buying a new Highlander.

9.8. What are the most common problems with Toyota Highlanders?

Common problems include transmission issues, excessive oil consumption, electrical problems, stripped engine bolts, fuel tank issues (2020 model), AC condenser problems (2020 model), and faulty head gaskets.

9.9. How can I ensure I’m buying a reliable used Toyota Highlander?

Research model years, obtain a vehicle history report, inspect the vehicle thoroughly, take a test drive, consider a pre-purchase inspection, and choose a reputable dealer like Miller Toyota in Boise.

9.10. What maintenance is required to keep a Toyota Highlander running smoothly?

Essential maintenance includes regular oil changes, fluid checks, tire maintenance, brake inspections, and tune-ups. Addressing common issues promptly can prevent them from escalating into more significant problems.

10. Conclusion: Making An Informed Decision

Choosing the right Toyota Highlander involves careful research, consideration of your needs, and a thorough inspection of the vehicle. By understanding the Toyota Highlander years to avoid and focusing on the more reliable options, you can increase your chances of finding a dependable SUV that will provide years of reliable service.

Remember to obtain a vehicle history report, inspect the vehicle thoroughly, and consider a pre-purchase inspection to identify any potential problems before you buy. And when you’re ready to make your purchase, visit millertoyota.net or stop by Miller Toyota in Boise to explore our extensive inventory and experience our exceptional customer service.

Ready to find your perfect Toyota Highlander? Visit millertoyota.net today to browse our inventory, schedule a test drive, and connect with our team of Toyota experts!