The best year for the Toyota Highlander is subjective and depends on individual needs and preferences; however, several model years stand out for their exceptional reliability and owner satisfaction, and you can explore them all at millertoyota.net. At Miller Toyota in Boise, Idaho, we understand the importance of finding a dependable SUV that fits your lifestyle. Discover the perfect Highlander for your needs and budget at millertoyota.net! We offer diverse Toyota vehicles to suit every need.
1. Toyota Highlander Generations Overview
To determine the best year for a used Toyota Highlander, it’s helpful to look at the different generations and their common issues. Each generation has its strengths and weaknesses, affecting long-term reliability and owner satisfaction.
1.1. First Generation (2001-2007)
The first generation Toyota Highlander was known for its comfortable on-road experience. Consumer Reports highlighted that the first-gen Highlander was roomier and less expensive than the Lexus RX. While the 2003 model suffered engine issues, the 2004, 2005, and 2007 models stood out for their reliability.
1.1.1. 2003 Toyota Highlander: A Model to Avoid
The 2003 Highlander is often cited as the worst model year of the first generation. CarComplaints.com details numerous engine issues, including stripped engine bolts and engine failure. Some owners reported needing to replace the entire engine.
1.1.2. 2004 and 2005 Toyota Highlander: Top Choices
The 2004 and 2005 Highlander models have impressive reliability scores, both earning a 4 out of 5 rating from Consumer Reports. Additionally, they boast perfect owner satisfaction ratings of 5 out of 5.
1.1.3. 2007 Toyota Highlander: Award Winner
The 2007 Toyota Highlander received CarComplaints’ “Seal of Awesome” award, indicating top-notch reliability. This model is a great choice if you’re looking for a reliable used midsize SUV.
1.2. Second Generation (2008-2013)
The second generation Highlander featured a larger size and improved ride quality. Consumer Reports recommends all models from this generation but notes that the 2008 model had some initial issues.
1.2.1. 2008 Toyota Highlander: A Rough Start
The 2008 Highlander had a rocky start with 13 recalls and over 300 NHTSA complaints, including airbag and labeling issues. Because of these problems, it’s best to avoid this model year.
1.2.2. 2009 Toyota Highlander: Highly Recommended
The 2009 Highlander received positive feedback from critics and owners. It earned the “Seal of Awesome” award from Car Complaints, with most mechanical issues being minor and easily fixable.
1.2.3. 2013 Toyota Highlander: Reliable and Dependable
The 2013 Highlander is another standout model from this generation, boasting high reliability and dependability scores. Consumer Reports noted very few trouble spots, mainly related to body integrity, such as roof trims and rubber moldings.
1.3. Third Generation (2014-2019)
The third generation Highlander grew again in size and received a significant styling update. It maintained many of the qualities of the previous generation.
1.3.1. 2015 Toyota Highlander: Most Complaints
The 2015 model year received the most complaints from this generation. Owners cited uncomfortable seats and excessive wind noise. While not deal-breakers, these issues led to numerous complaints from NHTSA users.
1.3.2. 2017-2019 Toyota Highlander: Excellent Choices
The 2017, 2018, and 2019 models are particularly reliable, offering excellent utility, fuel economy, and value.
1.4. Fourth Generation (2020-Present)
The fourth generation Highlander, launched in 2020, features the GA-K platform, which improves ride quality and handling. This generation has grown in both length and width.
1.4.1. 2020-Present Toyota Highlander: Solid Reliability
These Highlander SUVs have demonstrated solid reliability with minimal complaints and recalls. Consumer Reports recommends all models from this generation, giving them a reliability score of 4 out of 5. A minor issue reported is that the fuel tank may not fill up correctly, but this appears to be a wider Toyota issue.
2. Factors to Consider When Choosing a Toyota Highlander
When choosing the best year for a Toyota Highlander, several factors should influence your decision:
2.1. Reliability Ratings
Look at reliability ratings from reputable sources like Consumer Reports and J.D. Power. These ratings provide insights into how well a vehicle has performed over time and can help you avoid models with known issues.
2.2. Owner Reviews
Read owner reviews on sites like Edmunds and Kelley Blue Book. Real-world experiences can provide valuable information about the pros and cons of different model years.
2.3. Maintenance Records
Check the vehicle’s maintenance records to ensure it has been properly cared for. Regular maintenance is key to the longevity and reliability of any vehicle.
2.4. Safety Features
Consider the safety features offered in different model years. Newer models typically have more advanced safety technologies, such as lane departure warning and automatic emergency braking.
2.5. Budget
Set a budget and stick to it. The price of a used Toyota Highlander can vary widely depending on the model year, mileage, and condition.
3. Common Toyota Highlander Problems
Even the most reliable vehicles can have issues. Here are some common problems reported by Toyota Highlander owners:
3.1. Airbag Issues
Certain model years, including 2013, 2016, and 2020, have experienced airbag issues. Some Highlanders had airbags that failed to deploy upon collision. The 2020 models were recalled due to faulty trim covers that could hinder airbag deployment.
3.2. Head Gasket and Oxygen Sensor Failure
The 2001-2007 models sometimes had issues with overheating engines due to blown head gaskets and faulty oxygen sensors. This could lead to engine misfires and rough idling.
3.3. Interior Problems
The 2015 Highlander had complaints about uncomfortable seats, causing back pain during long drives and a malfunctioning audio system. The 2008 model had issues with a randomly activating panic alarm and a defective CD player.
3.4. Oil Leaks and Loss of Oil Pressure
Models from 2005-2013 experienced oil leaks and loss of oil pressure. This was often caused by a faulty variable valve timing-intelligent (VVT-i) gear and ruptured oil cooler line.
3.5. Ruptured Oil Lines
Ruptured oil lines can lead to engine failure due to a lack of oil, often requiring expensive repairs in 2005-2013 models.
3.6. Disconnected Air Filter Housing Hose
The 2001-2011 models were affected by a disconnected air filter housing hose, which can affect the vehicle’s air-fuel ratio and cause the engine to hesitate, stall, or rough idle.
4. In-Depth Look at Recommended Toyota Highlander Years
To make an informed decision, let’s examine the recommended Toyota Highlander years.
4.1. 2004 and 2005 Toyota Highlander
4.1.1. Reliability and Performance
The 2004 and 2005 Toyota Highlander models are highly regarded for their reliability and performance. These models typically feature a 3.3-liter V6 engine, offering a good balance of power and fuel efficiency. The engine provides around 230 horsepower, making it suitable for city and highway driving.
4.1.2. Features and Comfort
These Highlanders offer a comfortable ride with spacious seating for up to seven passengers. Standard features include air conditioning, power windows and locks, and a CD player. Higher trims may include leather upholstery, a sunroof, and upgraded audio systems.
4.1.3. Safety
Safety features include anti-lock brakes (ABS), front and side airbags, and vehicle stability control. These features ensure a safe driving experience for you and your passengers.
4.1.4. Potential Issues
While these models are generally reliable, some owners have reported minor issues such as:
- Oxygen sensor failures
- Minor oil leaks
Regular maintenance and timely repairs can mitigate these issues.
4.2. 2007 Toyota Highlander
4.2.1. Enhancements Over Previous Years
The 2007 Toyota Highlander includes several enhancements over the earlier models. It features a slightly updated design and improved interior materials.
4.2.2. Performance and Engine Options
The 2007 Highlander offers a choice between a 2.4-liter four-cylinder engine and a 3.3-liter V6 engine. The V6 engine remains the popular choice for its superior power and performance.
4.2.3. Interior and Technology
Inside, the 2007 Highlander features a more modern dashboard design and improved seating comfort. Available technology includes a navigation system, Bluetooth connectivity, and a premium JBL audio system.
4.2.4. Common Problems
Some of the common problems reported by owners include:
- Minor electrical issues
- Wear and tear on suspension components
Regular inspections and maintenance can help address these issues promptly.
4.3. 2009 Toyota Highlander
4.3.1. Key Improvements
The 2009 Toyota Highlander brought key improvements, including a more refined interior and updated technology features.
4.3.2. Engine and Transmission
The 2009 Highlander is equipped with a 3.5-liter V6 engine, producing around 270 horsepower. The engine is paired with a five-speed automatic transmission, offering smooth and efficient performance.
4.3.3. Interior Comfort and Features
The interior features comfortable seating for up to seven passengers, with available leather upholstery and heated front seats. Technology features include a rearview camera, Bluetooth connectivity, and an upgraded audio system.
4.3.4. Reported Problems
Some owners have reported issues such as:
- Water pump failures
- Power steering issues
Routine maintenance can help prevent these problems.
4.4. 2013 Toyota Highlander
4.4.1. Noteworthy Features
The 2013 Toyota Highlander is known for its reliability and family-friendly features. It offers a spacious interior, comfortable ride, and good fuel economy.
4.4.2. Performance
The 2013 Highlander comes with a 2.7-liter four-cylinder engine or a 3.5-liter V6 engine. The V6 engine is the more popular choice, offering better performance and towing capacity.
4.4.3. Interior and Technology
The interior is well-equipped with features like a touchscreen infotainment system, Bluetooth connectivity, and a rearview camera. Higher trims offer leather upholstery, a sunroof, and a premium audio system.
4.4.4. Typical Issues
Common issues reported by owners include:
- Body integrity issues (roof trims and rubber moldings)
- Minor electrical problems
Regular maintenance can address these issues effectively.
4.5. 2017-2019 Toyota Highlander
4.5.1. Updates and Enhancements
The 2017-2019 Toyota Highlander models received updates and enhancements, including refreshed styling, improved safety features, and updated technology.
4.5.2. Engine Options
These models offer a 3.5-liter V6 engine paired with an eight-speed automatic transmission. The engine delivers strong performance and good fuel economy.
4.5.3. Interior and Features
The interior features comfortable seating, high-quality materials, and a range of technology features, including:
- An updated infotainment system
- Advanced safety features such as lane departure warning
- Automatic emergency braking
4.5.4. Owner Satisfaction
These models have high owner satisfaction ratings, indicating a positive ownership experience.
4.5.5. Potential Issues
While these models are generally reliable, some owners have reported:
- Minor transmission issues
- Infotainment system glitches
Regular maintenance and software updates can mitigate these issues.
5. Why Choose a Toyota Highlander?
The Toyota Highlander stands out in the midsize SUV market for several reasons:
5.1. Reliability
Toyota is known for its reliability, and the Highlander is no exception. Many model years have excellent reliability ratings, ensuring a dependable vehicle.
5.2. Safety
The Highlander prioritizes safety, offering various advanced safety features that protect you and your passengers.
5.3. Comfort
With spacious seating and a comfortable ride, the Highlander is perfect for families and long road trips.
5.4. Versatility
The Highlander is versatile, offering ample cargo space and the ability to tow trailers or boats.
5.5. Resale Value
Toyota vehicles hold their value well, and the Highlander is no exception. This makes it a good investment in the long run.
6. Maintaining Your Toyota Highlander
Proper maintenance is essential to keep your Toyota Highlander running smoothly.
6.1. Regular Oil Changes
Follow the manufacturer’s recommended oil change schedule to keep the engine lubricated and prevent damage.
6.2. Tire Rotations
Rotate the tires regularly to ensure even wear and extend their lifespan.
6.3. Brake Inspections
Inspect the brakes regularly and replace them as needed to ensure safe stopping power.
6.4. Fluid Checks
Check and top off fluids such as coolant, brake fluid, and power steering fluid to keep the vehicle functioning properly.
6.5. Scheduled Maintenance
Follow the manufacturer’s recommended maintenance schedule for services such as spark plug replacement, timing belt replacement, and transmission service.
7. Toyota Highlander Alternatives
If the Toyota Highlander doesn’t quite fit your needs, several alternatives are worth considering:
7.1. Honda Pilot
The Honda Pilot is a popular midsize SUV known for its spacious interior, comfortable ride, and reliability.
7.2. Ford Explorer
The Ford Explorer offers a more rugged design and powerful engine options.
7.3. Chevrolet Traverse
The Chevrolet Traverse is a large midsize SUV with ample cargo space and seating for up to eight passengers.
7.4. Kia Telluride
The Kia Telluride offers a stylish design, luxurious interior, and a long list of standard features.
7.5. Hyundai Palisade
The Hyundai Palisade is known for its comfortable ride, upscale interior, and advanced technology features.
8. Visiting Miller Toyota in Boise, Idaho
When you’re ready to purchase a Toyota Highlander, visit Miller Toyota in Boise, Idaho. At millertoyota.net, you can explore our inventory, schedule a test drive, and speak with our knowledgeable staff.
8.1. Wide Selection of Vehicles
We offer a wide selection of new and used Toyota Highlanders to choose from.
8.2. Knowledgeable Staff
Our staff can answer your questions and help you find the perfect vehicle for your needs.
8.3. Financing Options
We offer a variety of financing options to fit your budget.
8.4. Service and Maintenance
Our service department can help you keep your Toyota Highlander running smoothly.
9. Search Intent
Here are five search intentions related to the keyword “What Is The Best Year For Toyota Highlander”:
9.1. Identifying the Most Reliable Toyota Highlander Model Years
Search Intent: Users want to find out which Toyota Highlander model years have the fewest problems and the highest reliability ratings.
9.2. Comparing Different Toyota Highlander Model Years
Search Intent: Users aim to compare the pros and cons of various Toyota Highlander model years to make an informed purchasing decision.
9.3. Understanding Common Problems and Issues with Toyota Highlanders
Search Intent: Users seek information about common problems and issues associated with specific Toyota Highlander model years to assess potential maintenance and repair costs.
9.4. Determining the Best Value for a Used Toyota Highlander
Search Intent: Users are interested in finding the Toyota Highlander model year that offers the best balance of price, features, and reliability in the used car market.
9.5. Seeking Recommendations from Experts and Owners
Search Intent: Users look for recommendations from automotive experts and current/past owners regarding the best Toyota Highlander model years based on real-world experiences and professional reviews.
10. FAQs: Determining the Best Toyota Highlander Year
Here are some frequently asked questions about the most reliable Toyota Highlander years:
Q: Which Year of Highlanders Are Best?
A: The best years for the Toyota Highlander include the 2004, 2005, and 2007 models from the first generation and the 2017-2019 models from the third generation. These years have demonstrated high reliability, minimal complaints, and good owner satisfaction ratings.
Q: Are Older Toyota Highlanders Good Cars?
A: Yes, older Toyota Highlanders, especially from the first generation (2001-2007), are considered good cars. However, avoid the 2003 model due to its engine issues.
Q: Which Is More Reliable, Honda Pilot or Toyota Highlander?
A: Both are known for their reliability. The Toyota Highlander generally has a slight edge in reliability ratings, especially in the recommended years.
Q: Were There Any Significant Recalls for the Second-Generation Highlanders?
A: Yes, the 2008 Highlander had 13 recalls and complaints, particularly related to airbag issues and incorrect labeling.
Q: What Is the Most Common Problem with Toyota Highlanders?
A: Common problems include airbag issues, head gasket failures, oil leaks, and interior problems, depending on the model year.
Q: How Long Do Toyota Highlanders Typically Last?
A: Toyota Highlanders typically last for 200,000 to 300,000 miles with proper maintenance.
Q: What Are the Best Years for Fuel Efficiency in Toyota Highlanders?
A: The hybrid models and newer models (2017-2019) tend to have better fuel efficiency.
Q: Are Toyota Highlanders Expensive to Maintain?
A: Toyota Highlanders are generally not expensive to maintain compared to other midsize SUVs, thanks to Toyota’s reliability.
Q: What Should I Look for When Buying a Used Toyota Highlander?
A: When buying a used Toyota Highlander, check the maintenance records, look for signs of rust or damage, and have a mechanic inspect the vehicle.
Q: Do Toyota Highlanders Hold Their Value Well?
A: Yes, Toyota Highlanders hold their value well due to their reputation for reliability and durability.
11. Conclusion: Your Next Steps
Choosing the best year for a Toyota Highlander depends on your specific needs and budget. Models from 2004, 2005, 2007, and 2017-2019 are highly recommended due to their reliability and owner satisfaction. Visit millertoyota.net to explore our inventory, schedule a test drive, and find the perfect Toyota Highlander for you and your family. At Miller Toyota, we are dedicated to helping you find a dependable SUV that enhances your lifestyle. Explore our extensive selection of Toyota vehicles online at millertoyota.net or visit our dealership in Boise, Idaho, today. Find your dream Highlander now! Contact us at +1 (208) 376-8888 or visit us at 208 N Maple Grove Rd, Boise, ID 83704, United States.
