The Toyota Tacoma has carved out a stellar reputation since its introduction in 1995. Initially a compact pickup, it evolved into a midsize powerhouse by its second and third generations, becoming a favorite for off-road enthusiasts and everyday drivers alike. Known for its robust engine and available six-speed manual transmission, a used Toyota Tacoma can be an excellent choice for adventure. However, not all model years are created equal. To ensure your Tacoma experience is thrilling for the right reasons, it’s crucial to know which years to approach with caution.
Navigating the used car market can be tricky, especially when considering the Tacoma, a vehicle known for its longevity. While generally reliable, certain model years have been plagued with issues that could turn your dependable pickup into a source of frustration. This guide is designed to steer you clear of potential pitfalls and help you pinpoint the best used Toyota Tacoma years for your needs.
QUICK RECOMMENDATION: Steer Clear of Toyota Tacoma Model Years 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2011, 2012, 2016, and 2017.
These model years have collectively received numerous complaints and reports of significant problems. The 2006, 2007, and 2008 Tacomas, in particular, are notorious for body and paint issues, alongside engine troubles.
The 2009 model year carries forward some of these concerns, with interior accessory malfunctions and persistent body, lighting, and engine defects reported by owners.
Moving into the early 2010s, the 2011 Toyota Tacoma stands out for widespread issues across various components. While the 2012 model’s primary faults lie in the drivetrain and engine, the later 2016 and 2017 models echo these drivetrain and engine concerns and add unreliable transmissions to the mix.
The 2016 and 2017 Toyota Tacomas are particularly concerning due to their transmission problems, which can pose a safety hazard. However, the 2007 model shouldn’t be overlooked either, primarily due to the potentially exorbitant repair costs associated with its common issues, making it equally unfavorable in the used market.
Image alt text: Timeline of Toyota Tacoma generations, highlighting the evolution of the truck from its compact beginnings to a mid-size pickup, aiding buyers in identifying different models.
Toyota Tacoma Years That Are Safe Bets on the Used Market
Despite the handful of years to avoid, the Toyota Tacoma boasts a long history filled with dependable models. Choosing a reliable year model is key to enjoying the legendary off-road capability and durability the Tacoma is known for. We highly recommend considering the following Toyota Tacoma year models when searching for a used truck, as they are generally considered safe buys with fewer reported major defects.
Top Reliable Tacoma Year Models:
- 1995 Toyota Tacoma
- 1996 Toyota Tacoma
- 1997 Toyota Tacoma
- 1998 Toyota Tacoma
- 1999 Toyota Tacoma
- 2000 Toyota Tacoma
- 2001 Toyota Tacoma
- 2002 Toyota Tacoma
- 2003 Toyota Tacoma
- 2004 Toyota Tacoma
- 2005 Toyota Tacoma
- 2010 Toyota Tacoma
- 2013 Toyota Tacoma
- 2014 Toyota Tacoma
- 2015 Toyota Tacoma
- 2018 Toyota Tacoma
- 2019 Toyota Tacoma
- 2020 Toyota Tacoma
The first generation Tacomas, from 1995 to 2004, are celebrated for their exceptional reliability. Complaints are minimal, often surfacing only after these trucks have surpassed 100,000 miles. While minor issues can occasionally appear earlier, they are typically inexpensive to resolve, often around $500.
The 2014, 2018, and 2019 Tacoma models are also reliable, though slightly less so than the earlier generations. While they exhibit a similar number of defects, these issues tend to surface earlier in the vehicle’s lifespan. Owners have reported issues like premature seat wear or air conditioning malfunctions before reaching 40,000 miles. Vibration problems have also been noted in the 2018 and 2019 models. These are usually minor fixes, but worth noting. The 2013 Toyota Tacoma shares similar vibration and drivetrain concerns but has a higher complaint volume, making it a slightly less robust choice compared to 2014, 2018 and 2019.
The 2005 Toyota Tacoma is generally reliable, with most complaints relating to paint issues like chipping and peeling, typically occurring after 80,000 miles. These are primarily cosmetic concerns. The 2010 and 2015 year models carry a slightly elevated risk of early engine or brake problems, such as squeaking or worn brake components. However, these occurrences are infrequent enough that they shouldn’t be a major deterrent.
While these later models are generally good choices, the 2020 Toyota Tacoma stands out as exceptionally reliable, with virtually no complaints reported, making it arguably the safest bet among used Tacomas. CoPilot confidently recommends all of these Toyota Tacoma year models as solid used vehicle choices.
Image alt text: A lineup of various Toyota Tacoma models from the recommended reliable years, showcasing the diverse styles and generations of dependable Tacomas available for used car buyers.
Toyota Tacoma Years to Avoid: Models Prone to Problems
When you set your sights on a Toyota Tacoma, you’re likely envisioning a vehicle ready for adventure, one that’s tough, capable, and dependable on and off the road. While most Tacomas deliver on this promise, certain model years have shown significant flaws that should give potential buyers pause. We strongly advise against purchasing the following Toyota Tacoma year models due to their history of reliability issues.
Least Reliable Tacoma Year Models:
- 2006 Toyota Tacoma
- 2007 Toyota Tacoma
- 2008 Toyota Tacoma
- 2009 Toyota Tacoma
- 2011 Toyota Tacoma
- 2012 Toyota Tacoma
- 2016 Toyota Tacoma
- 2017 Toyota Tacoma
The 2006, 2007, and 2008 Toyota Tacoma models are plagued by paint problems, including chipping and peeling, and more seriously, reports of transmission and engine failures. Notably, the 2006 Tacoma frame is susceptible to rust and breakage around 100,000 miles, with repair costs potentially exceeding $3,500.
The 2007 model year stands out as particularly problematic. Owners have reported issues ranging from sticky accelerators and peeling paint to more severe mechanical failures, leading to repair bills between $5,000 and $10,000 in some instances. The 2008 and 2009 Toyota Tacomas may present issues earlier in their lifespan, which, while potentially less costly, can be more dangerous, such as sudden acceleration and clutch slippage.
The 2011 Tacoma is known for headlight problems (flickering, cracked covers, etc.) and a recurring clicking noise. The 2012 model is characterized by numerous engine defects and significant vibration during driving. These issues often appear around the 30,000-mile mark for both models.
The 2016 and 2017 model years raise serious safety concerns, making them particularly undesirable. Both have numerous reports of transmission problems, and the 2016 Tacoma is infamous for engine failures. These trucks have been reported to exhibit wandering issues and improper shifting, especially in cold conditions. While avoiding all listed years is advisable, the 2007, 2016, and 2017 models are particularly risky due to the severity and potential cost of their problems.
Image alt text: A collection of Toyota Tacoma models from the years identified as problematic, serving as a visual guide for buyers to recognize and potentially avoid these less reliable model years.
Common Problems Across Toyota Tacoma Years
Even beyond the specific “years to avoid,” it’s helpful to be aware of common issues that have been reported across various Toyota Tacoma model years. Understanding these potential problems can help you make a more informed decision when purchasing a used Tacoma, regardless of the year.
- Peeling Paint: A recurring cosmetic issue, many Tacoma owners have reported paint peeling, particularly on the roof, for no apparent reason. Repainting can be costly, potentially reaching $3,000.
- Faulty Transmission: Transmission issues have been noted in higher-mileage Tacomas from 1995 to 2015. The cause is often attributed to an incorrectly adjusted throttle position sensor or a defective solenoid.
- Lower Ball Joint Issues: Tacomas from 1995 to 2007 have experienced premature wear on the lower ball joints, leading to stiff steering and self-centering problems, often accompanied by noises from the front suspension.
- Faulty Starter: While Tacoma engines are generally robust, starter motor failures have been reported in higher-mileage vehicles. Replacement is typically the most effective solution.
- Suspension Corrosion: Certain 2005-2011 Tacomas were recalled for rear leaf spring corrosion. However, not all affected vehicles were included in the recall, leaving some owners with replacement costs between $400 and $800.
- Engine Misfires and Stalls: The 2016 and 2017 Tacomas had recalls for a faulty crank position sensor causing stalling. Similar to suspension issues, not all vehicles were covered, potentially resulting in a $200 repair for some owners.
- Bluetooth Connectivity Issues: Owners of the 2019 Tacoma have reported problems with Bluetooth connectivity, including dropped connections, sometimes during phone calls.
- Vehicle Speed Control Problems: Unintended acceleration has been reported, posing a significant safety risk. Recalls were issued for 2004-2010 models to address this issue.
- Oil Leaks: Some Tacoma models can suffer from oil leaks due to crankshaft seal failure on the front timing cover. DIY repair is possible for those with mechanical skills, saving on labor costs.
Is a Used Toyota Tacoma a Worthwhile Purchase?
The Toyota Tacoma’s popularity as the best-selling midsize pickup truck in the US is a testament to its appeal. Its off-road prowess, strong reliability ratings, and excellent resale value make it a desirable choice for many. But is buying a used Toyota Tacoma a smart decision?
While Tacomas are generally reliable, particularly older models, they aren’t without their drawbacks, especially in the used market. Many argue that the Tacoma was due for a significant update in terms of design and engine technology years ago. Older models may exhibit these age-related issues more prominently. If you’re seeking a thoroughly modern midsize truck, a used Tacoma might not be the best fit.
However, the Tacoma’s legendary reliability, especially in older models, means they can still offer long-term value. Be prepared to pay a premium, as Tacomas hold their value exceptionally well. For buyers prioritizing durability and off-road capability over the latest tech and design, a used Tacoma, particularly from the reliable years, remains a solid choice.
FAQs: Reliable Toyota Tacoma Years
Q: Which Toyota Tacoma years are most recommended for reliability?
A: Toyota Tacoma models from 1995 to 2005, along with 2010, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2018, 2019, and 2020, are highly recommended due to their strong reliability. These years have fewer complaints and are known for longevity, often exceeding 100,000 miles with minimal problems.
Q: What are the common problems in less reliable Tacoma years?
A: The Toyota Tacoma Years To Avoid—2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2011, 2012, 2016, and 2017—have reported issues including body and paint defects, engine problems, faulty interior accessories, drivetrain and engine malfunctions, and unreliable transmissions.
Q: Are Toyota Tacomas from the early 2000s trustworthy?
A: Yes, early 2000s Tacoma models, specifically 2000 to 2005, are considered very reliable. Complaints are minimal and typically involve minor issues that surface only after significant mileage accumulation.
Q: How reliable is the 2020 Tacoma model?
A: The 2020 Tacoma is considered exceptionally reliable, with virtually no major complaints reported, making it one of the safest used Tacoma choices.
Q: Is the Toyota Tacoma a good truck overall?
A: Absolutely. The Toyota Tacoma has been a leading midsize pickup since 1995, renowned for its off-road capability and reliability. While some years are better than others, the Tacoma generally enjoys a strong reputation for dependability.
Q: What’s the typical cost of a new Toyota Tacoma?
A: The 2023 Toyota Tacoma starts at approximately $29,500 for the base SR5 trim and can exceed $50,000 for the top-tier TRD Pro, depending on options and dealer charges.
Q: What’s the average price of a used Toyota Tacoma?
A: Used Toyota Tacoma prices vary significantly by year and condition. Expect to find 15-year-old models starting around $7,500. Later models, particularly those with low mileage and desirable trims, can approach new car prices due to strong resale value. For example, a 2016 Toyota Tacoma Double Cab might average around $29,675, reflecting a premium over original market forecasts.
Finding Your Reliable Used Toyota Tacoma
Finding a reliable used Toyota Tacoma doesn’t have to be a daunting task. With the right information and tools, you can confidently navigate the used car market. Utilize resources like the CoPilot car shopping app to streamline your search and identify the best used Tacoma options in your area. By focusing on the reliable model years and being aware of potential issues, you can increase your chances of driving away in a Tacoma that’s ready for any adventure you have in mind.
