The Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander are consistently top contenders in the competitive midsize SUV market. Both vehicles offer spacious interiors, reliable performance, and family-friendly features, making them popular choices for families across America. Choosing between these two excellent SUVs can be challenging, as highlighted in discussions among car enthusiasts and real-world owner experiences. This article dives deep into a comparison of the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander to help you determine which SUV best meets your needs.
Performance and Driving Experience
When it comes to performance, both the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander offer capable engines suitable for daily driving and family adventures. The Highlander has been noted for a somewhat “lifeless steering” feel, which can detract from the driving enjoyment for some. This can be a significant factor for drivers who appreciate a more engaging driving experience. Upgrading the wheels and tires can subtly alter the handling dynamics of an SUV. While opting for larger 18″, 19″, or 20″ wheels might offer a slightly sharper steering response, it’s crucial to consider the trade-offs. Larger, heavier wheels can increase unsprung mass, potentially leading to longer braking distances, a less comfortable ride, and increased wear on suspension components. Choosing lightweight, quality wheels is essential to minimize any negative impact on performance when considering wheel upgrades.
Conversely, the Honda Pilot is often praised for a more solid and “truckish” feel, despite being built on a car-based platform like the Highlander. This can translate to a more confident and stable feeling on the road, which is appealing to drivers who prioritize a robust driving experience.
Interior and Practicality
Inside, both SUVs offer three rows of seating, but differences emerge in terms of space and flexibility. The Toyota Highlander’s back seat has been described as somewhat small, and its split-folding third-row design can compromise either passenger space or cargo capacity. This can be inconvenient for families who frequently need to balance both passengers and luggage.
The Honda Pilot generally offers a more spacious third row and a more versatile interior configuration, making it easier to accommodate both passengers and cargo. The Pilot’s more flexible seating and cargo arrangements are often cited as advantages for families with growing needs.
Trim Levels and Options
Navigating the trim levels and options can be a different experience with each brand. Toyota’s approach with the Highlander involves numerous packages and options, which can make it challenging to find the exact configuration you desire. Finding a Highlander with the specific features and color you want might require more searching and compromise. Honda, on the other hand, typically offers a more streamlined approach with trims like LX, EX, EX-L, and Touring for the Pilot. This simplified structure makes it easier to choose a trim level and color and finalize your purchase, appreciated by buyers who prefer a straightforward buying process.
Styling and Design
Exterior styling is subjective, but it’s a factor many buyers consider. The Toyota Highlander is often perceived as having a more “carlike” appearance, which may appeal to some but not to others. The Honda Pilot, particularly in its redesign, is often described as having a more “butch” and SUV-like aesthetic, which resonates with buyers seeking a more rugged and traditional SUV look.
Value and Pricing
When considering overall value, trade-in offers and pricing can significantly influence the final decision. Anecdotal evidence suggests that Honda dealerships may offer more competitive trade-in values compared to Toyota dealerships. Combined with potentially less negotiation room on the Highlander’s price, the Honda Pilot can emerge as a more financially attractive option, potentially saving buyers a few thousand dollars.
Platform and Construction
While both the Highlander and Pilot are car-based SUVs, their underlying platforms contribute to their driving feel. The Highlander is based on the Toyota Camry platform, which is known for its car-like comfort and handling. The Honda Pilot, while still car-based, is perceived to have a more “truckish” platform, contributing to its solid and capable feel. This difference in platform can influence the perceived robustness and driving dynamics of each SUV, even though both are fundamentally designed for on-road family use rather than heavy-duty off-roading.
Conclusion
Choosing between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander ultimately depends on individual priorities and preferences. If a more engaging driving experience, a more spacious and flexible interior, and a simpler trim selection process are paramount, the Honda Pilot may be the preferred choice. If a car-like ride and a wide array of customization options are desired, the Toyota Highlander remains a strong contender. Both SUVs offer reliability and family-friendly features, making either a solid choice. Carefully consider your needs and test drive both vehicles to determine which SUV is the better fit for your family.
