The Toyota Tacoma has been a popular pickup truck since its introduction in 1995, earning accolades and strong sales figures. Initially a compact pickup, it evolved into a midsize truck by its second and third generations. Known for its off-road prowess, often equipped with a powerful engine and a six-speed manual transmission, the Tacoma is a solid choice for adventure seekers. However, to ensure your off-road experiences are enjoyable and not marred by mechanical issues, choosing a reliable year model is crucial. This guide, brought to you by the auto experts at Miller Toyota, will help you navigate the used Tacoma market to find the best year for your needs and steer clear of models with known problems.
Toyota Tacoma Years to Avoid: Quick Guide
Before diving into the best options, let’s quickly address the Toyota Tacoma year models that you should generally avoid. Based on owner reports and common issues, we recommend being cautious with the following years: 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2011, 2012, 2016, and 2017 Toyota Tacoma models.
These years have been associated with a higher number of complaints and potential reliability concerns. Specifically, the 2006, 2007, and 2008 models have faced significant issues related to body and paint, as well as engine problems.
The 2009 Tacoma has been reported to suffer from faulty interior accessories and various defects in lights, body, and engine components.
The 2011 year stands out due to widespread problems across virtually all vehicle systems. While the 2012 Tacoma’s main issues are focused on the drivetrain and engine, the 2016 and 2017 models unfortunately share similar engine and drivetrain malfunctions, coupled with unreliable transmissions.
The transmission problems in the 2016 and 2017 Tacomas are particularly concerning, potentially making these trucks unsafe to drive. Furthermore, the high repair costs associated with the 2007 model also make it a less desirable option in the used market.
Reliable Toyota Tacoma Year Models: Your Best Bets
If you’re looking for a used Toyota Tacoma that offers reliability and peace of mind for your on-road and off-road adventures, there are many excellent year models to choose from. Focusing on dependable models will allow you to experience the legendary Tacoma reputation without the worry of encountering major defects.
Highly Recommended Tacoma Years:
- 1995 Toyota Tacoma
- 1996 Toyota Tacoma
- 1997 Toyota Tacoma
- 1998 Toyota Tacoma
- 1999 Toyota Tacoma
- 2000 Toyota Tacoma
- 2001 Toyota Tacoma
- 2002 Toyota Tacoma
- 2003 Toyota Tacoma
- 2004 Toyota Tacoma
- 2005 Toyota Tacoma
- 2010 Toyota Tacoma
- 2013 Toyota Tacoma
- 2014 Toyota Tacoma
- 2015 Toyota Tacoma
- 2018 Toyota Tacoma
- 2019 Toyota Tacoma
- 2020 Toyota Tacoma
Toyota Tacomas manufactured between 1995 and 2004 are renowned for their exceptional reliability, with minimal reported issues. Most complaints for these models are related to minor defects that typically surface after the truck has accumulated over 100,000 miles. While there’s a small chance of encountering a problem within the first 50,000 miles, any such issues are usually inexpensive to repair, often around $500 or less.
The 2014, 2018, and 2019 Tacoma models are also considered reliable choices, although slightly less so than the earlier generations. While they exhibit a similar number of defects to the older models, these issues tend to appear earlier in the vehicle’s lifespan.
Reports of premature seat wear or air conditioning unit failures have surfaced before the 40,000-mile mark for these newer models. Additionally, vibration issues have been noted in both the 2018 and 2019 models, occurring relatively early. These problems are generally considered minor and easily rectified but are worth noting. The 2013 Toyota Tacoma shares similar vibration and drivetrain concerns but with a higher frequency of complaints, making it slightly less robust compared to the 2014, 2018, and 2019 models.
The 2005 Tacoma year model has a moderate number of complaints, primarily concerning paint chipping and peeling, which usually occurs after 80,000 miles. This is largely a cosmetic issue and not a major mechanical concern. The 2010 and 2015 year models present a slight possibility of early engine or brake problems, such as squeaking or worn brake pressure plates. However, the likelihood of these issues is low enough that they shouldn’t be a significant deterrent.
While all these listed year models are generally recommended, the 2020 Toyota Tacoma stands out as the safest bet overall, boasting a remarkably low number of reported complaints. Ultimately, Miller Toyota recommends any of these Toyota Tacoma year models for used car buyers seeking a dependable truck.
Toyota Tacoma Years to Avoid in Detail
While many Tacoma years are dependable, certain models have a history of problems that can lead to expensive repairs and frustration. Knowing which years to avoid is just as important as knowing the best years. These are the least reliable Toyota Tacoma year models that we advise against purchasing:
Tacoma Models with Reliability Concerns:
- 2006 Toyota Tacoma
- 2007 Toyota Tacoma
- 2008 Toyota Tacoma
- 2009 Toyota Tacoma
- 2011 Toyota Tacoma
- 2012 Toyota Tacoma
- 2016 Toyota Tacoma
- 2017 Toyota Tacoma
The 2006, 2007, and 2008 Toyota Tacoma models are plagued by paint chipping and peeling issues, alongside more serious transmission and engine failures. A particularly alarming issue with the 2006 model is frame rust and breakage, often occurring around 100,000 miles and costing upwards of $3,500 to repair.
The 2007 year model is among the least desirable Tacomas on the used market. Owners have reported a range of problems, including sticky accelerators, peeling paint, and other significant defects, leading to repair bills ranging from $5,000 to $10,000 in some instances. The 2008 and 2009 Toyota Tacomas may exhibit less costly but potentially more dangerous issues early in their lifespan, such as sudden acceleration and clutch slippage.
2011 Tacoma models are known for headlight problems, including flickering lights and cracked covers, as well as a recurring clicking sound. The 2012 models suffer from numerous engine defects and significant vibrations while driving. Notably, these issues in both the 2011 and 2012 models tend to emerge around the 30,000-mile mark.
Even more concerning are the 2016 and 2017 year models, which raise safety concerns. Both years have numerous reports of transmission problems, and the 2016 model is infamous for its faulty engine. These trucks have been known to exhibit wandering issues and improper shifting, especially in cold weather conditions. While avoiding all the listed years is recommended, the 2007, 2016, and 2017 models are particularly advised against due to their significant safety and reliability risks.
Common Problems Across Toyota Tacoma Generations
While the Toyota Tacoma enjoys a strong reputation for reliability, certain recurring issues have been reported across various model years. Being aware of these common Toyota Tacoma problems can help you make a more informed purchasing decision and know what to look for during a pre-purchase inspection:
- Peeling Paint: A widespread cosmetic issue, particularly in older models, is paint peeling, especially on the roof. Repainting can be costly, potentially reaching up to $3,000.
- Faulty Transmission: Transmission problems have been reported in Tacomas ranging from 1995 to 2015, often in higher mileage vehicles. The cause is often attributed to a misadjusted throttle position sensor or a defective solenoid.
- Lower Ball Joint Issues: First and second-generation Tacomas (1995-2007) have experienced premature wear on the lower ball joints. This can lead to steering difficulties and noises from the front suspension.
- Faulty Starter: While Tacoma engines are generally reliable, starter motor failure can occur in higher mileage vehicles. Replacement is typically the most practical solution.
- Suspension Corrosion: Corrosion in the rear leaf spring suspension led to recalls in some 2005-2011 Tacomas. However, not all vehicles were included, leaving some owners with replacement costs.
- Engine Misfires and Stalls: The 2016 and 2017 Tacomas had recalls for a faulty crank position sensor that could cause engine stalling. Again, not all vehicles were covered by the recall.
- Bluetooth Connectivity Issues: Owners of the 2019 Tacoma have reported problems with Bluetooth connectivity, including dropped connections during calls.
- Vehicle Speed Control Problems: Unintended acceleration has been reported in some 2004-2010 models, leading to recalls to address this serious safety concern.
- Oil Leaks: Some Tacoma models may experience oil leaks from a failing crankshaft seal on the front timing cover. DIY repair is possible for mechanically inclined owners.
Is a Used Toyota Tacoma a Good Purchase?
The Toyota Tacoma remains a top choice in the midsize pickup truck segment for good reasons. Its off-road capabilities, strong reliability in many model years, and excellent resale value are major draws for buyers. As the best-selling midsize pickup, the Tacoma clearly has a lot to offer.
However, it’s important to acknowledge that the Tacoma design, both exterior and engine, is considered by some to be dated. Older models, in particular, may show their age in terms of features and technology. If you’re seeking a cutting-edge midsize truck, a used Tacoma might not be the most modern option.
Despite this, the inherent reliability of many Tacoma year models ensures they can last for many years with proper maintenance. Be prepared to pay a premium for a used Tacoma due to their strong resale values.
FAQs: Toyota Tacoma Reliability
Q: Which Toyota Tacoma years are the most reliable?
A: For optimal reliability, consider Toyota Tacoma models from 1995 to 2005, as well as 2010, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2018, 2019, and 2020. These years generally have fewer complaints and are known for their longevity.
Q: What problems are common in less reliable Tacoma years?
A: Toyota Tacoma years to avoid, such as 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2011, 2012, 2016, and 2017, have been associated with issues ranging from cosmetic paint problems and faulty accessories to serious engine, transmission, and drivetrain defects.
Q: Are early 2000s Tacoma models trustworthy?
A: Yes, Tacoma models from the early 2000s (2000-2005) are generally very reliable. They have a low rate of reported problems, and issues that do arise are often minor and appear at higher mileages.
Q: How reliable is the 2020 Toyota Tacoma?
A: The 2020 Tacoma is considered exceptionally reliable, with very few owner complaints, making it one of the safest used Tacoma purchases.
Q: Is the Toyota Tacoma a good truck overall?
A: Absolutely. The Toyota Tacoma is a highly regarded midsize pickup truck, consistently ranking as a best-seller due to its ruggedness, off-road capability, and proven reliability across many model years. While some years are better than others, the Tacoma nameplate generally represents quality and durability. For detailed comparisons of Tacoma model years, refer to resources specializing in Toyota Tacoma reliability ratings.
Q: What is the typical cost of a used Toyota Tacoma?
A: Used Toyota Tacoma prices vary significantly based on year, trim, mileage, and condition. Expect to find older, higher mileage Tacomas (15+ years old) starting around $7,500. However, due to their strong resale value, newer, low-mileage used Tacomas, especially recent models, can command prices close to or even exceeding their original MSRP. Market conditions and location also play a role in pricing.
Finding Your Reliable Used Toyota Tacoma
Finding the best year for a used Toyota Tacoma for your needs requires careful research and inspection. By focusing on the reliable year models and being aware of potential problem areas, you can increase your chances of purchasing a Tacoma that will provide years of dependable service, both on and off the road. Always conduct a thorough pre-purchase inspection by a qualified mechanic to assess the specific condition of any used vehicle you are considering.
