The midsize SUV market is fiercely competitive, but for those prioritizing longevity, utility, and unwavering reliability in a used vehicle, the Toyota Highlander stands out as a top contender. Owners frequently boast about reaching 200,000 miles and beyond with their Highlanders, with some even reporting figures between 350,000 and 500,000 miles with regular maintenance and parts replacement. Toyota’s renowned reputation for durability makes the Highlander a compelling choice for used car buyers.
But with several model years available, prospective buyers often ask: what is the best year for a Toyota Highlander when considering reliability?
This guide dives into the various generations of the Toyota Highlander, from its inception in 2001 to the current models, to pinpoint the most reliable model years to buy used and which ones you might want to approach with caution. Let’s explore the optimal choices for your next dependable SUV.
Decoding Toyota Highlander Reliability by Generation
Let’s break down the Toyota Highlander’s history generation by generation to identify the sweet spots for reliability in the used market.
First Generation Toyota Highlander (2001-2007)
The first generation Toyota Highlander (2001-2007) carved a niche for itself by prioritizing on-road comfort and handling, unlike many SUVs of its time that focused on off-road capabilities. Toyota achieved this refined driving experience through the Highlander’s four-wheel independent suspension and unibody construction.
This generation is fondly remembered for its well-rounded nature and pleasant driving dynamics. Consumer Reports highlighted that the original Highlander offered more space and a more accessible price point compared to its luxury sibling, the Lexus RX. Among the seven model years in this generation, Consumer Reports recommended the 2003, 2004, 2005, and 2007 Highlanders.
However, the 2003 Toyota Highlander, while generally solid, is flagged as a year to potentially avoid. CarComplaints.com data indicates the 2003 Highlander as the worst year within this generation, citing significant engine problems such as stripped engine bolts and, in severe cases, engine failure requiring complete replacement.
For the most reliable choices within the first generation, the 2004 and 2005 model years emerge as strong contenders. Both years earned reliability scores of 4 out of 5 from reputable sources and achieved perfect 5 out of 5 owner satisfaction ratings, signaling dependable vehicles that owners were happy with. Furthermore, the 2007 Highlander also stands out as an excellent used midsize SUV option, receiving CarComplaints’ “Seal of Awesome” award for its exceptional reliability record.
Alt text: Silver 2004 Toyota Highlander parked on a paved road, showcasing its first-generation design known for on-road comfort.
Second Generation Toyota Highlander (2008-2013)
The second generation Toyota Highlander, starting with the 2008 model, marked a significant redesign. It grew in size, adopting a more traditional midsize SUV appearance, moving away from the slightly wagon-like profile of the first generation. This generation also brought improvements in ride quality, emphasizing a comfortable and smooth driving experience.
Consumer Reports generally recommends all models within the second generation (2008-2013). However, the 2008 Highlander presents a cautionary tale. It experienced a less-than-smooth launch, accumulating 13 recalls and over 300 complaints registered with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Notably, the 2008 Highlander faced three recalls related to airbag issues and incorrect labeling. Therefore, proceeding with caution or avoiding the 2008 model year is advisable.
Toyota demonstrated a commitment to addressing the initial issues of the 2008 Highlander, and subsequent years in this generation showed improvements in reliability. The 2009 Highlander is particularly noteworthy, garnering positive feedback from both automotive critics and owners. It received the “Seal of Awesome” award from Car Complaints, and reported mechanical issues were typically minor and easily resolved.
The 2013 Highlander also stands out as a highly reliable model from the second generation. It consistently received high reliability and dependability scores from various automotive journalism outlets. Consumer Reports noted very few trouble spots for the 2013 Highlander, primarily minor body integrity issues such as roof trim and rubber molding concerns. By 2013, Toyota had effectively refined the second-generation Highlander, resulting in a more robust and dependable SUV.
Alt text: Dark gray 2013 Toyota Highlander front quarter view, highlighting the redesigned, larger body style of the second generation.
Third Generation Toyota Highlander (2014-2019)
The third generation Highlander (2014-2019) continued the trend of growth in size and introduced a more contemporary styling update. Beyond aesthetics, the third generation largely maintained the positive attributes of its predecessor.
Similar to the second generation, Consumer Reports awarded its coveted recommendation to all models within the third-generation Highlander lineup. Every model year from 2014 to 2019 achieved a perfect reliability score of 5 out of 5. Owner satisfaction ratings were also strong, with 4 out of 5 for the 2014-2018 models, although the 2019 model saw a slight dip to 3 out of 5 in owner satisfaction.
CarComplaints.com data indicates the 2015 model year received the highest number of complaints within this generation. Common owner concerns included uncomfortable seats and excessive wind noise, although these issues are generally considered less severe than major mechanical failures. Despite these complaints, the 2015 Highlander remains a reasonably reliable vehicle. However, if you are looking to pinpoint the absolute most reliable years within this generation, you might consider focusing on other years.
For peak reliability within the third generation, the 2017-2019 Toyota Highlander models are particularly strong choices. These years consistently demonstrate excellent reliability, utility, fuel economy, and overall value.
Alt text: Interior view of a 2017 Toyota Highlander dashboard, showcasing the updated interior design and features of the third generation.
Fourth Generation Toyota Highlander (2020-Present)
The fourth generation Toyota Highlander, launched in 2020, introduced the GA-K platform, a new architecture designed to enhance ride quality and handling. Continuing the growth trend, the Highlander further increased in both length and width.
Early data suggests that the fourth generation Highlanders (2020-present) exhibit robust reliability with minimal complaints and no significant widespread recalls reported so far. Consumer Reports also recommends all current models within this generation, with each receiving a reliability score of 4 out of 5. This indicates that any fourth-generation Highlander is generally a safe bet when purchasing used.
A minor issue reported in some fourth-generation Highlanders is related to the fuel tank not filling up to its full capacity. However, this appears to be an issue affecting various Toyota models and is likely being addressed by the manufacturer.
In conclusion, determining the best year for a Toyota Highlander reveals a landscape of generally reliable vehicles. Even older generations offer model years that are considered safe and dependable used car purchases.
Common Toyota Highlander Reliability Issues
While the Toyota Highlander enjoys a strong reputation for reliability, some recurring issues have surfaced across different model years:
- Defective Airbags (2013, 2016, and 2020 Models): Instances of airbags failing to deploy in collisions have been reported. Notably, over 3,300 Highlander and Highlander Hybrid models from 2020 were recalled due to potentially faulty trim covers that could impede the deployment of seat-mounted side airbags.
- Head Gasket and Oxygen Sensor Failure (2001-2007 Models): Overheating engines due to blown head gaskets and malfunctioning oxygen sensors have been reported in earlier models, leading to engine misfires and rough idling.
- Interior Problems (2015 and 2008 Models): The 2015 Highlander received complaints about uncomfortable seats causing back pain on long drives and audio system malfunctions. The 2008 model faced issues with randomly activating panic alarms and defective CD players.
- Oil Leaks and Loss of Oil Pressure (2005-2013 Models): Owners have reported observing engine oil puddles and smelling burning oil inside the cabin, often attributed to a faulty variable valve timing-intelligent (VVT-i) gear and ruptured oil cooler lines.
- Ruptured Oil Lines (2005-2013 Models): This issue can lead to engine failure due to oil starvation, potentially requiring costly repairs.
- Disconnected Air Filter Housing Hose (2001-2011 Models): This problem can disrupt the vehicle’s air-fuel mixture, resulting in engine hesitation, stalling, or rough idling.
FAQs: Most Reliable Toyota Highlander Year
Q: Which year of Highlanders are best for reliability?
A: Based on the generation-by-generation analysis, the most reliable Toyota Highlander years include the 2004, 2005, and 2007 from the first generation, and the 2017-2019 models from the third generation. These years consistently score high in reliability surveys and demonstrate strong owner satisfaction.
Q: Are older Toyota Highlanders still good used cars?
A: Yes, older Toyota Highlanders, particularly those from the first generation (2001-2007), can be excellent used car choices. They are known for their comfortable ride and inherent reliability. However, it’s wise to exercise caution with the 2003 model due to reported engine issues.
Q: In terms of reliability, is the Honda Pilot or Toyota Highlander better?
A: Both the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander are recognized for their reliability within the midsize SUV segment. While both are dependable, the Toyota Highlander often holds a slight edge in overall reliability ratings, particularly in the recommended model years highlighted in this guide.
Q: Were there significant recall issues with the second-generation Highlanders?
A: Yes, the 2008 Highlander, which launched the second generation, had a challenging start with 13 recalls and numerous complaints, primarily concerning airbag malfunctions and incorrect labeling.
Find Your Reliable Used Toyota Highlander
Looking for the best year Toyota Highlander for your needs? The CoPilot car shopping app simplifies your search for a reliable used car. Tell CoPilot what you’re looking for, and it will scan dealership inventories in your area to create a personalized list of top car listings that match your criteria.
CoPilot uses the same advanced technology that dealerships use, giving you access to more in-depth vehicle information than other platforms. And because CoPilot operates independently of dealerships, you receive unbiased recommendations, free from sponsored listings or hidden agendas. Discover more about CoPilot’s approach on our About Us page and start your search for the perfect reliable used Toyota Highlander today!
Alt text: Screenshot of the CoPilot car shopping app interface on a smartphone, displaying a curated list of used cars with vehicle details.
