The Toyota Gr86 and Nissan 370z represent two distinct approaches to the affordable sports car formula. While a direct comparison between the latest GR86 and a now-discontinued 370z might seem unusual, potential buyers often cross-shop these two due to their focus on driving engagement. This comparison, based on a back-to-back test drive of a 2022 GR86 (automatic) and a 370z Sport (automatic), examines key performance and feature differences to help you decide which might be the better fit.
Engine and Powertrain: A Tale of Two Approaches
The 370z boasts a potent V6 engine, renowned for its reliability and high-end power. However, its low-end torque felt somewhat lacking during the test drive, possibly due to the use of regular fuel instead of the recommended premium. The GR86, with its smaller four-cylinder boxer engine, felt noticeably quicker in everyday driving scenarios, offering a more engaging experience around town. While the 370z promised more comfortable highway cruising, its fuel economy significantly trails the GR86. The 370z’s VQ37VHR engine holds a reputation for bulletproof reliability, while the long-term durability of the GR86’s FA24 engine remains to be seen.
Steering and Handling: Finding the Right Balance
Despite its heavier weight, the 370z impressed with its precise turn-in, minimal body roll, and communicative hydraulic steering. It felt more enjoyable to push through corners than some of its modern competitors. The GR86, known for its agility and responsiveness, likely holds an advantage on the track or autocross course due to its lighter weight. However, for spirited street driving, the 370z provided a compelling experience.
Transmission: Modern vs. Mature
The GR86’s automatic transmission clearly outshone the 370z’s. Shifting with the paddles felt snappier and more aggressive in the GR86, complemented by the selectable driving modes (Eco, Sport, Track). The 370z’s automatic, while functional, felt less refined and responsive.
Interior, Ride Quality, and Seating: Comfort vs. Connection
The 370z’s dated interior lacked the modern amenities of the GR86, although this could be addressed with aftermarket upgrades. Surprisingly, the 370z offered a roomier cabin and a more compliant ride, absorbing road imperfections better than the GR86. However, the GR86 provided a lower, more engaging driving position, enhancing the connection with the road. The 370z’s higher seating position and awkward hood bulges detracted slightly from the sporty driving experience.
Price and Running Costs: Value Proposition
Pricing a used 370z can be challenging, with significant variation depending on condition and mileage. A well-maintained 370z can offer significant performance for the price, but potential maintenance costs and lower fuel economy should be considered. A new GR86, while more expensive upfront, benefits from modern technology, better fuel efficiency, and a factory warranty.
Conclusion: Choosing Your Champion
The 370z and GR86 cater to different preferences within the sports car spectrum. The 370z leans towards a grand touring experience, prioritizing power and comfort, while the GR86 emphasizes agility and pure driving enjoyment. The best choice depends on individual priorities and driving needs. Factors like desired features, budget, and long-term ownership costs should all be weighed when making a decision. A test drive of both models is highly recommended.
